Saturday, March 14, 2015

Spilling Tea, Choking on Silence and Perhaps Burning Bridges

I'm not a bestselling author. I'm not a degree-holding academic feminist who purports to validate the romance genre by reading it. I'm an author and reader of color who grew up with a certain amount of upper middle class and model minority privilege — none of which holds any weight in the publishing industry. Because, you see, like most of my fellow writers of color, I am invisible.

The past few weeks saw Stephanie Dray, a white author of historical fiction, "joking" about writing Thomas Jefferson-Sally Hemings BDSM romance. Women of color expressed hurt on Twitter, and those issues were later outlined more extensively in the blogosphere here and here. Dray made sure to seek absolution from well-known authors like Courtney Milan, Mary Robinette Kowal and Jenny Trout, and Beverly Jenkins lauded her for her apology. Ultimately the fracas became centered on Trout, Anne Rice and Jaid Black. Slavery and rape were forgotten. The black women hurt by the comments were forgotten. White authors with a bigger followings were having some feelings, so that took precedence.


It always takes precedence.

Author Racheline Maltese noticed some offensive social media advice from the March issue of RWA's RWR magazine. It instantly spurred Twitter discussion amongst romance writers about neutrality, being "nice" and how having polarizing opinions on gay marriage and Ferguson is important. And then male SFF author Chuck Wendig weighed in, because apparently he was "asked" to and felt he should. The women — particularly minority women who are always marginalized — involved in the discussion may as well have vanished into thin air. And some of us couldn't even express that thought without it becoming about a white author with a bigger following.

Because it always takes precedence.

And, of course, within the romance publishing blogosphere, there were only tumbleweeds and crickets from the most popular corners. Perhaps the whisper of broom bristles as the ugliness of things like slavery and Ferguson were swept under the rug.

All we want to do is write and be read. How can we flourish at that when our own community won't read us?

Publishing is populated by gatekeepers and town criers...ones who, intentionally or no, decide who gets in and who gets heard. And, over and over, the same people are locked out and silenced. It's a pattern. It's been the pattern for decades. And hashtagging diversity and putting a bunch of diversity panels on your conference schedule is nice lip service, but doesn't do a damn thing to change what's actually been happening and what will continue to happen.

I can't speak for others, but I know what has stood out to me. Being called out as racist by a white woman for thinking Idris Elba is kinky.  Seeing a white woman say that my stories are misogynist and 'veer dangerously toward Orientalizing.' Watching every aspect of my story get nitpicked and analyzed when similar romances by white women are just taken at face value. As separate incidents, as book reviews, it all may seem like no big deal. I don't cry into my Cheerios because someone doesn't like my writing or what I have to say on social media. But taken together? Stacking it up? Seeing how my fellow authors of color go through the same things? All we want to do is write. All we want is to be read. Why are those simple desires so much like pounding on the door of a locked room, screaming to be let out?

Of course, most of us don't scream. Most stay quiet. Most don't want to rock the boat. Invisibility, in some ways, is more secure than being seen as a troublemaker, as someone who wants to upset the apple cart and change the industry status quo.

Because that status quo takes precedence. Make no mistake, it always takes precedence.

41 comments:

  1. Wow. This is so interesting and important. And it's something I don't see. I see what blows up in my feed, and like others, I only saw the white thoughts and white outrage on these various issues, because that is what was retweeted, etc.

    I will make an effort to check this precedent in my own reading. Thank you for bringing it to my attention.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for reading! For the most part, it is always the white thoughts and white outrage that gets RT'd.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sharing on FB and twitter. Cherri, it might also help to friend/follow some authors of color. There were a few on Twitter commenting on this but it is very easy to get drowned out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes! You're so right, Seressia. Oftentimes, WOC don't have nearly as much of a signal radius...which is just another form of erasure. The more we are followed and friended, the more we're actually heard.

      Delete
    2. Yes! Yesterday after I read this post I added a bunch of new folks to my feed. I tend to keep my feed small, but I need to be better at keeping my feed full of WOC.

      Delete
  4. Thank you for writing this post Sulekha. I'm going to share it everywhere I can. The silence suffered by WOC authors is nearly soul shattering. But we need to talk about it. The more we talk, the more people become aware. The more people become aware, change can happen. At least that is my hope.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Dren. I keep hoping that talking about it will force some change -- even a little -- or at least start the ball rolling for the next generation of writers.

      Delete
  5. I've already touched base with you on Twitter, but I also wanted to leave a comment. This piece cuts right to the heart and expresses what many female authors of color are thinking. I too was enraged by the careless words of Stephanie Dray, but was more enraged how easily the storm passed. However, reading your words gave me solace in knowing that I am not alone in my feelings.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Dahlia. We're far, far from alone. I think there's an ongoing frustration that the storm always passes.

      Delete
  6. Great insight that I wholeheartedly agree with...I saw how quickly "we" were expected to move on and get over it. Over and over and over again.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Michelle. It's amazing, isn't it? When we look back at the pattern and how it constantly repeats? When is it ever going to change? When will we ever see real movement and growth?

      Delete
  7. Suleikha, I'm part of a Multicultural Romance group with Dahlia. She sent me here to your blog.

    We need voices like yours. WE NEED YOU.

    I am hosting an online, real-time panel about diversity in fiction. We will do a brief version on Sunday, March 29 (3-4 PM EDT) on Facebook, and then my publisher is going to help me set up an additional, bigger event at a later date.

    Would you like to join?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for saying voices like mine are needed! Unfortunately, I'm not active on Facebook at all. I check mine perhaps once every six months.

      Delete
  8. Suleikha Snyder~

    A poster linked your blog on Amazon in a discussion relating to Jenny Trout and a box set which included her story, as well as those of other authors, being pulled due to people calling her publisher (which I believe was instigated by Anne Rice's comments about Trout).

    I'm very glad I found your post. It made me think about the issues in a different way. I have read the thoughts of many women of color regarding the historical fiction book, so their voices aren't being completely lost.

    Thank you so much for helping me learn more.

    Here's where your blog was linked on Amazon.

    http://www.amazon.com/forum/top%20reviewers/ref=cm_cd_et_md_pl?_encoding=UTF8&cdForum=Fx2Z5LRXMSUDQH2&cdMsgID=Mx3EBVUQX0P0VCR&cdMsgNo=7811&cdPage=313&cdSort=oldest&cdThread=TxCFFAMA0L2YKU#Mx3EBVUQX0P0VCR

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's kind of adorable that somebody thinks I don't know where the attack on Jenny Trout came from. I'm fully aware of the goings-on. I just wanted to talk about the impact of it all on women of color!

      At any rate, I'm glad my post made you think about the issues differently.

      Delete
    2. Would you like to come on the thread and chat? I'd love to talk with you there.

      Delete
    3. On Amazon? No thank you. I stay out of that realm.

      Delete
  9. Will reblog on Wordpress, if you don't mind.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What do you mean by reblog? You can link to this, but I'd rather not have any content pasted wholesale. Thanks!

      Delete
  10. All I know is this ish is still rolling along like the Mississippi and no amount of hash tag activism is quelling it. The disingenuousness of the Big Five sickens me as much as their "determined effort to find" good manuscripts by WOC. After hearing of, and being exposed to the shell games they pull, this writer of color has zero fucks left to give. And as far as allies? Please. Do you mean the ones who hog the spotlight and in a show of solidarity mention "other" writers as an aside while plugging their latest "edgy multicultural" tome? Or the ones who really reach across this huge divide and cross-promote? Those, I can count on the fingers of one hand with two digits chopped off. I used to doubt myself but not anymore. I'm a good writer. A damned good writer. I've come to one conclusion: the chosen, the ones with LOW melanin, who write "multicultural" (hate that word with a vengeance) for an audience who are similarly melanated, are the ones that the Big Five WANT to write "multicultural." They will continue to get the contracts because they are a known quantity. They have a built in audience from their White oriented books They pen the "other" just the way their regular audience likes (not too ethnic, not too real, not too angry). I no longer care about NY's approval because NY has cultivated the reading public it has and KNOWS it can't change it anytime soon. Me. I'll keep writing for those who appreciate my stuff.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think New York is going to eventually realize that sticking to their known quantities means stagnating. And by then it'll be too late, because self-publishing will be the norm instead of the outlier.

      Delete
  11. As a Vest Manufacturer, we understand the importance of creating high-quality and reliable vests for our customers. Our focus is on providing durable and comfortable vests that are perfect for any occasion. We use only the best materials to create our products, ensuring they will last for years to come. Whether you're looking for a vest to wear while working outside or one that's stylish enough for a night out on the town, we have something that will fit your needs perfectly. Our team of experts works tirelessly to ensure that each vest is designed with both form and function in mind. So if you're looking for top-notch quality and exceptional customer service, look no further than Vest Manufacturer! Vest Manufacturer

    ReplyDelete
  12. Are you in search of a reliable and new design socks Manufacturer? Look no further! Our company specializes in crafting premium-grade socks that are comfortable, durable, and stylish. We understand the importance of providing clients with exceptional merchandise that speaks to their needs and preferences. That's why we have an extensive range of sock styles to choose from, including athletic socks for sports enthusiasts, dress socks for formal occasions, and casual socks for everyday wear. Our manufacturing process is top-notch, ensuring that every pair is made with precision and care. We use only the finest materials to ensure maximum comfort and longevity. Plus, our team includes skilled designers who can create custom designs tailored to your brand or individual style. With our commitment to quality products at competitive prices, we're confident that you won't find a better Socks Manufacturer on the market! Socks Manufacturer

    ReplyDelete
  13. The thorough research evident in your posts gives me confidence in the accuracy of the information presented. Keep up the scholarly work!toilet cubicle Easy-to-clean surfaces ensure that restroom maintenance is a straightforward and hygienic process.

    ReplyDelete
  14. In the cacophony of whispers and hushed conversations, the atmosphere became charged with unspoken secrets, as if the air itself was brimming with spilled tea. Yet, amidst the gossip and clandestine exchanges, a profound silence loomed, suffocating and unyielding. It was as if the weight of withheld truths and concealed emotions had become an insurmountable force, causing those entangled in the web of whispers to choke on the very silence they maintained.
    How to get a No Fault Divorce in New York

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thank you for sharing this wonderful post. Don't stop, please. I think your knowledge is quite valuable. Please visit my website if you have any questions concerning IT, software, or hardware. We would be happy to help you whenever you need it; simply click the following link to follow us.
    IT service provider

    ReplyDelete
  16. I enjoyed reading the article above, really explains everything in detail, and the article is very interesting and effective. Thank you and good luck with the upcoming articles. abogado conducción imprudente charlotte va

    ReplyDelete
  17. Find the awesome, perfect and hot female to make your night unforgettable.

    ReplyDelete
  18. https://www.okbima.com/health-insurance/cancer-insurance-plans

    ReplyDelete
  19. Best insecticide for your Cabbage, Chilli, Red Gram, Rice is trendly now available online at nurture.retail app
    Tebuconazole 10 + sulphur 65 wg dose | Bifenthrin 10 ec uses

    ReplyDelete
  20. "Suleikha Snyder's Blog: A vibrant tapestry of romance, culture, and empowerment. Dive into a world where love knows no boundaries, as Suleikha crafts captivating tales that celebrate diversity and resilience. From steamy encounters to poignant narratives, discover the magic of storytelling that transcends expectations and ignites the heart."uncontested divorce in virginia beach





    ReplyDelete
  21. Hiring an experienced attorney is crucial when dealing with traffic infractions in Fairfax. Our company specializes in deftly and devotedly managing the complexity of traffic legislation. With a thorough grasp of regional laws and a dedication to defending your rights, we work hard to get the best result for each and every client. From DUI accusations to speeding tickets, we offer individualized legal tactics made just for your circumstances. Put your faith in our skilled team to fight for you, guaranteeing a right and fair conclusion to any traffic-related lawsuits in Fairfax.Abogado Tráfico Fairfax

    ReplyDelete
  22. New York cheap divorce services offer affordable options for couples seeking to dissolve their marriage, New York Cheap Divorce providing cost-effective solutions while ensuring legal compliance and timely resolution.

    ReplyDelete
  23. In order to successfully navigate the intricate legal system around traffic infractions in Fairfax, Virginia, one needs seasoned legal counsel. As an experienced traffic lawyer, I provide thorough legal assistance catered to your particular situation. Whether you are charged with DUI, reckless driving, or receiving a speeding ticket, my goal is to protect your rights and get the best result for your case.Abogado Tráfico en Fairfax VA

    ReplyDelete
  24. Choose the relevant visa category, fill out the necessary paperwork, pay the necessary costs, and show up for a visa interview at the American embassy or consulate in India to apply for immigration to the United States. Seek the advice of an immigration specialist.
    how to apply for us immigration from india

    ReplyDelete
  25. Your attorney will offer tactical guidance on how to handle matters including property distribution, spousal support, child custody, and visitation rights. They'll put in the effort to get you the greatest result possible.Fairfax Motivos para Divorcio Abogado

    ReplyDelete
  26. The storytelling approach used in this article captivated my attention from start to finish. Well-crafted narrative!

    ReplyDelete
  27. Not only is Vlone Hoodie apparel a medium for his artistic expression, but it goes beyond that. Every Hoodie showcases a unique approach to fashion with its striking patterns, thought-provoking sayings, and recognizable images.

    ReplyDelete